Current:Home > NewsShe said she killed her lover in self-defense. Court says jury properly saw her as the aggressor -WealthTrack
She said she killed her lover in self-defense. Court says jury properly saw her as the aggressor
View
Date:2025-04-13 20:28:55
RALEIGH, N.C. (AP) — The North Carolina Supreme Court upheld the murder conviction of a woman who fatally shot her lover in her bedroom, ruling Friday that the trial judge gave appropriate instructions to the jury about the legal limits for deadly force inside a home.
Five of the seven justices agreed to overturn a unanimous appellate decision that had ordered a new trial for Wendy Dawn Lamb Hicks, who was convicted in the death of Caleb Adams. Evidence shows he was shot twice in the back in her bedroom doorway.
The majority’s primary opinion said it was proper, based on evidence, for the jury to be instructed that Hicks could not cite self-defense and the protection of one’s home to justify deadly force if the jury could infer that she was acting as the aggressor, even if she did not instigate the confrontation.
Adams was married to someone else and began a relationship with Hicks after they met at work in 2015.
The relationship was tumultuous and strained, marked by the use of drugs and efforts by Hicks to reveal the relationship to Adams’ wife, possibly through texts and sexually explicit photos, according to the opinion written by Associate Justice Anita Earls.
Adams arrived at Hicks’ Randolph County home on the morning of June 13, 2017 — even though she had warned him not to come. Evidence shows that within minutes, Hicks called 911 and said she had shot Adams. He died at the scene.
Her teenage daughter was in another room, so “Hicks is the only living eyewitness to what occurred in the bedroom where Mr. Adams was shot,” Earls wrote.
The jury convicted Hicks, now 44, of second-degree murder in 2019 and she was sentenced to a prison term of 15 to 18 years.
The Court of Appeals found that trial Judge Bradford Long had erred by giving unsupported jury instructions on the aggressor doctrine. But Earls wrote that inconsistencies between Hicks’ testimony and prior accounts and other evidence challenged her version of events and warranted that instruction.
Hicks described a violent attack and said she shot Adams while trying to avoid his blows, but she exhibited no obvious injuries and the prosecution’s evidence shows he was shot in the back from at least 6 inches (15 centimeters) away, the opinion said.
“Drawing all inferences in the state’s favor, a jury examining the evidence could reasonably infer that Ms. Hicks acted as the aggressor in her confrontation with Mr. Adams,” Earls wrote. “Each of those contradictions in the evidence could have given a jury pause,” prompting them to doubt Hicks’ account, she added.
In a dissenting opinion, Associate Justice Tamara Barringer focused largely on Hicks’ testimony and declared that the judge shouldn’t have given the “aggressor doctrine” instruction.
Hicks said in court that Adams took a gun from her nightstand and pointed it at her, demanding her phone. Then, Hicks said, he threw the gun and the phone onto her bed, after which she took the gun and phone. She testified that Adams blocked her way and physically attacked her when she tried to leave the bedroom.
Hicks “retained the right to protect herself and the other people in her home, even when Mr. Adams turned to face away from her,” Barringer wrote.
Squaring the self-defense and aggressor provisions in North Carolina statutes and case law raises “complicated and thorny legal issues that call out for clarity,” Associate Justice Richard Dietz wrote in a separate opinion backing the prevailing result.
But these issues were not sufficiently addressed by the legal parties in the case, Dietz said and “as a result, not only does the law suffer, but so does Hicks.”
veryGood! (59987)
Related
- Spooky or not? Some Choa Chu Kang residents say community garden resembles cemetery
- Chris Evans’ Wedding Ring Is on Full Display After Marrying Alba Baptista
- Netflix plans to open brick and mortar locations
- NYC lawmaker arrested after bringing a gun to protest at Brooklyn College
- From family road trips to travel woes: Americans are navigating skyrocketing holiday costs
- Microsoft closes massive deal to buy Call of Duty maker Activision Blizzard
- 5 killed in Mexico prison riot. Authorities cite dispute between inmates
- GOP quickly eyes Trump-backed hardliner Jim Jordan as House speaker but not all Republicans back him
- Why members of two of EPA's influential science advisory committees were let go
- GOP quickly eyes Trump-backed hardliner Jim Jordan as House speaker but not all Republicans back him
Ranking
- The Super Bowl could end in a 'three
- Golden Bachelor's Joan Vassos Shares Family Update After Shocking Exit
- In Israel’s call for mass evacuation, Palestinians hear echoes of their original catastrophic exodus
- North Carolina Medicaid expansion still set for Dec. 1 start as federal regulators give final OK
- $73.5M beach replenishment project starts in January at Jersey Shore
- How to Slay Your Halloween Hair, According Khloe Kardashian's Hairstylist Andrew Fitzsimons
- Palestinians flee within Gaza after Israel orders mass evacuation and stages brief ground incursions
- LeVar Burton will host National Book Awards ceremony, replacing Drew Barrymore
Recommendation
See you latte: Starbucks plans to cut 30% of its menu
US oil production hits all-time high, conflicting with efforts to cut heat-trapping pollution
Trump Media's funding partner says it's returning $1 billion to investors, with many asking for money back
Prosecutor files case against Argentina’s frontrunner Javier Milei days before presidential election
Sonya Massey's father decries possible release of former deputy charged with her death
Hamas 'Day of Rage' protests break out in Middle East and beyond
Ada Sagi was already dealing with the pain of loss. Then war came to her door
How to protect your eyes during the ring of fire solar eclipse this weekend